Obama signs a law “with regrets”
Obama’s decision hardly provoked applause from the NDAA’s critics. The ACLU statedthat it was a “blight on his legacy because he will forever be known as the president who signed indefinite detention without charge or trial into law.†Jonathan Turley has called Obama’s decision to sign the NDAA into law America’s “Mayan momentâ€â€”the dooming moment “when the nation embraced authoritarian powers with little more than a pause between rounds of drinks.â€
On the other hand, two legal scholars with strong civil-liberties credentials and close ties to the administration, Marty Lederman and Steven Vladeck, authored a serious review of the NDAA’s most controversial terms and found them to be a mixed bag, but far from a civil-liberties apocalypse. The measure can fairly be called the “Gitmo Forever†Act because it contains a series of provisions designed to frustrate Obama’s pledge to close the detention operations at Guantánamo. On the other hand, as the result of effective lobbying by the White House and civil libertarians, the worst of the provisions concerning what the military calls “detention operations†were reshaped into provisions that are either relatively harmless or sound statements of law.
Surely both of these views can’t be right?
Fantastic. Â One of those signing statements we’ve always been concerned about.
Your nausea at Obama comes in here.:
The question therefore becomes not what Barack Obama’s Justice Department would do with the NDAA, but what a Rick Santorum or Mitt Romney Justice Department would do. And on that score, Turley’s concerns, though melodramatic, are far from unrealistic.
And with that I note the protesters I saw hitting Obama on NDAA. Â I suppose this would happen with or without “Occupy”, a loose figleaf of a movement to cover “it all”. Â I had to stop to catch what they were hitting at, and then people walked past and I heard this comment:
“Oh. Â I thought they were protesting Whole Foods”.
Hm. Â Might as well throw that into the mix as well. Â It’s all connected, or something, right?